When you look at the current American experience, especially this week with the ongoing investigations of the Jan. 6 commission, it is easy to see how the problems among us are not the wild-eyed, superpowered demons we see in many films on the screen. Instead, the real threat to us is often one that is far more personal, direct, and nearby.
Kate Bush wasn’t the only singer-songwriter to address these kind of themes.
In 1972, Loretta Lynn recorded “The Pill,” a controversial song that wouldn’t be released for another three years—after the passage of Roe v. Wade. The song centered around a woman who was unhappy with being pregnant year after year and finally having the ability to control her reproductive rights. Lynn herself had six children—four before she was 20 years old—and the song, which she had a writer’s credit in, seemed to reflect her experience.
Many country stations refused to play it, but the song itself was still popular and it did not later hurt her career as she followed it up with successful albums and film credits.
When Dolly Parton wrote “Down From Dover,” she took on some pretty tough subject matter. A young woman discovers she is pregnant, but her boyfriend is not around. She waits, trying to conceal the pregnancy, hoping her boyfriend will come home before she is discovered. He doesn’t, and when she is discovered, her family kicks her out of their lives.
My folks weren’t understanding, when they found out they sent me from the home place
My daddy said if folks found out he’d be ashamed to ever show his face
My mamma said I was a fool, she did not believe it when I told her
One of the greatest problems facing us in regards to the debate about women’s reproductive rights is that there are no off-ramps. Parton’s lyrics discussed women being shunned and cast out, ridiculed by their own families. Would ending abortion solve that problem, or make it worse? Considering the outright assault on sex education in the United States, it is pretty clear to me that the only answer for some is no answer at all, unless that answer is to go on the attack against women.
We have a long way to go before November. In so many ways, we are trying to maintain that energy in the face of an onslaught of Republican desire to shut hope down.
Are we “Running Up That Hill?” Or can we run downhill toward success?